knowledge base284 articles
knowledge base/seo & search
glossary term

"'Soft 404' in Search Console Explained"

Updated

A page that looks like an error or empty page to Google but tells it everything is fine, so Google leaves it out of search.

What it means

A soft 404 is a page that shows visitors a "not found" message, an error, or an almost empty page, while telling search engines that the page loaded successfully. Google spots the mismatch, treats the page as missing, and keeps it out of search results.

Some background helps. Every time a browser or Googlebot asks for a page, the server answers with a status code before sending the page. 200 means "here's the page", 404 means "nothing here", and 301 means "this moved permanently, go here instead". A hard 404 is a server honestly answering 404. A soft 404 is a server answering 200 for something that is, for all practical purposes, a missing page.

Why it matters

A page flagged as a soft 404 won't appear in Google Search. That's correct if the page really is gone, but it's a real problem when an important page gets flagged by mistake, which happens more often than you'd expect.

There are three different situations behind this status, and each has a different fix:

Situation Typical example What Google wants
The page is gone and has no replacement A discontinued product shows "This item is no longer available" A real 404 or 410 status code
The page moved An old service page shows a friendly "we've moved" note A 301 redirect to the new page
The page is real but looked broken to Google A page whose content loads from scripts that Google couldn't fetch, or a page with very little on it A page that loads its content properly for Googlebot

Common causes of the third case: content that loads by script and fails for Googlebot, files the page needs being blocked by robots.txt, too many or very large resources, server errors while rendering, a prominent error message during loading, and pages that are close to empty, such as a search results or category page with no results.

How to fix it

  1. Find the flagged pages. In Search Console, open Indexing → Pages, and click Soft 404 in the "Why pages aren't indexed" table to see example addresses.
  2. See what Google saw. Click the inspect icon next to an address, then Test live URL, then View tested page to see a screenshot of how Google rendered it. If the screenshot is blank or shows an error your visitors don't see, you're in the third situation.
  3. If the page is gone for good, make your server return a real 404 (or 410) status code. A custom "page not found" design is fine for visitors, but the status code underneath has to say 404. A page that was emptied or replaced with a "no longer available" message, rather than deleted, is the usual way to end up here.
  4. If the page moved, set up a permanent 301 redirect from the old address to the new one, then inspect the old address to confirm it redirects. See 301 vs. 302 redirects.
  5. If the page is real and should be indexed, fix whatever stopped it loading for Googlebot: unblock any scripts or styles blocked in robots.txt, fix server errors, and make sure the main content is present without relying on things that fail to load. If the page is genuinely thin, such as an empty category, add real content or remove the page.
  6. Tell Google you've fixed it. Back on the Soft 404 details page, click Validate fix. Google says validation typically takes up to about two weeks, sometimes longer. For one urgent page, use Request indexing on its inspection result instead. See how to request indexing.

A word of caution about a popular shortcut: redirecting lots of removed pages to your homepage. A visitor who wanted a specific product and lands on the homepage has effectively hit a dead end anyway. Google's guidance for a removed page with no replacement is simply a 404. Redirect only to a genuinely equivalent page; otherwise let the old page return a 404.

Google's crawl error troubleshooting guide covers soft 404s in more detail.

ask datanephew

Why is this page showing as a soft 404?

Ask datanephew to inspect the page. It reads the URL inspection result from Search Console for free, including the status code Google got and whether the page loaded properly, so you can tell a page that's really gone from one that just looked broken to Google.

Which of my soft 404 pages actually matter?

Ask datanephew to list your soft 404 pages alongside their past search clicks and visits from Google Analytics. Pages that used to bring in traffic are the ones to fix first; old pages nobody visits can usually just return a 404.

Can datanephew fix soft 404s for me?

Not directly. Changing status codes or redirects happens in your site's settings or code, which datanephew can't edit. Once you've fixed the pages, on the Owner plan it can resubmit your sitemap and notify IndexNow-supporting search engines like Bing; you'd click Validate fix in Search Console yourself.